Tweet
Register | Login | Sign up to our newsletter
Wannabe Hacks
 
  • Advice
    • Getting started
    • How to guides
    • Production
    • Reporting
    • Tools
    • Writing
  • Comment
    • Debate
    • Expert Insight
  • Finding a job
    • Applications
    • CVs
    • Interviews
    • Work experience
  • Guest posts
  • Industries
    • Digital and online
    • Magazine
    • Newspaper
    • Photojournalism
    • Radio
    • Television
  • Routes into journalism
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Postgraduate course
    • Freelancing
    • Shifts
    • Short course and NCTJ
    • Training schemes
    • Undergraduate course
    • Work experience and interning
    • Student media
  • How to guides
  • Podcast
  • Video
13. October, 2011 Comment, Postgraduate course, Short course and NCTJ
This article has 2 comments

Diversity in journalism part 1: can diversity schemes change the face of the newsroom?

by Hannah Bass

When it comes to race, UK journalism is a whitewash. Fewer than 7% of journalists and editors come from ethnic minority backgrounds, according to the Professional Publishers Association (PPA). Given that most of the UK’s journalism industry is based in London, where ethnic minorities make up over 30% of the population, this is clearly an under-representation.

Once young adults from ethnic minorities have made it to university, there are fought-over schemes and bursaries to encourage diversity in journalism. PPA runs MagNet, a scheme which pairs ethnic monitority students with a mentor from the industry. PPA says that this scheme gives students the opportunity “to overcome any barrier caused by his or her racial group” while helping “media owners to engage outstanding new talent”.

All of which sounds great, but there’s a catch. The students must already be studying on a PTC-accredited postgraduate journalism course.

Similarly, The Scott Trust sponsors the Journalism Diversity Fund which helps put aspiring journalists from ethnic minorities through NCTJ-accredited courses. But these courses are usually dominated by students educated at the UK’s top universities. It’s in access to these universities that the problem lies.

Last month almost a quarter of UK universities and colleges were slammed for failing to meet their own targets for admitting students from disadvantaged backgrounds – a demographic in which ethnic minorities are still disproportionately overrepresented. Year on year Oxbridge colleges famously admit black students in single figures.

Diversity schemes like MagNet and Journalism Diversity Fund are wonderful for encouraging wannabe hacks from ethnic minority who have made it to higher education. They also serve to highlight the lack of diversity as a problem at the heart of this country’s journalism.

But the problem goes far deeper than these schemes can reach. There is only so much that the journalism industry can do while the school system fails to get students from diverse backgrounds into universities. What the industry could do is to target ethnic minority students before they’ve left school. Work placements and mentors for students at GCSE level could promote journalism as an aspiration among under-represented groups.

But as long as the industry relies on employing university graduates while our university populations do not reflect our national diversity, these schemes are but a drop in the ocean.

Related posts:

  1. Applying for the Journalism Diversity Fund The other week, I took part in a Guardian Careers...
  2. Are the media racist? Or is it in fact a class issue? The New Statesman has recently compiled shocking statistics which show...
  3. Diversity in journalism part 2: women journalists and ‘women’s writing’ Looking round a City Journalism lecture, I see a mass...
  4. My Telegraph rejection proves grad schemes still place high value on national cuttings Two weeks ago, I received an generic email from the...
  5. How to apply for the BBC’s trainee schemes Who wouldn’t want to work for the BBC? A job...
2 comments
  Livefyre
  • Get Livefyre
  • FAQ
Sign in
+ Follow
Post comment
 
Link
Newest | Oldest
tinbaths
tinbaths 5pts

As an ethnic minority myself, who's just graduated with a first in an undergraduate journalism course, it seemed to me that the postgraduate courses is where a lot of the industry opportunities begin. Having applied for a more specific MA, I was disheartened to learn that I'd have to pay £500 simply to reserve my place on the course. I was relying on either the Scott Trust, AHRC or the George Viner support - however you don't hear if you've been awarded this money until you're about to practically start the course. In the end, I had to withdraw my application. Doing an MA isn't the be all and end all, but of course there may be a number of ethnic minority graduates who studied History for example and would like to do a journo MA but just can't afford it.

Elsewhere one great scheme which is offered is this three-month journo placement at the FT for the minoriti: http://summerinternships.pearson.com/about-programme.htm

mhd_bass
mhd_bass 5pts

@tinbaths Thanks for letting us know about the FT scheme! Definitely agree that the industry reliance on postgrad is a massive barrier in reflecting more diverse backgrounds in journalism.

Register  |  Login

@wannabehacks

Podcasts


Recommended

“Embrace the fear” and other lessons from my time in student media
6 / 12 / 2012 1 comment

After finishing my stint in student media, I couldn’t help but look

Read more

Student media and a degree: getting the balance
22 / 11 / 2012 28 comments

The time is 5.09am, and the birds are twittering outside my window.

Read more

Receiving feedback and learning from criticism
12 / 11 / 2012 1 comment

I don’t know what I was expecting when I opened that email.

Read more


Comments


  • Jenni Graham

    _JenniGraham on Finding a job in journalism: Which websites are the best?

    kpedersen03 I wasn't sure how to answer your question, so I asked WH readers on Twitter what they would write in...
    Posted Jun 18, 2013
  • kpedersen03 on Finding a job in journalism: Which websites are the best?

    Yet another fantastic post there! What about journalism.co.uk - it's quite a labour-intensive registration process - so I would like...
    Posted Jun 18, 2013
 
About

Wannabe Hacks is a living, breathing journalism resource. All our content is produced by aspiring journalists. Our aim is to offer an insight into the different routes into journalism, provide in-depth commentary about the big issues and stimulate discussion around what matters to you.

Current Editors: George Berridge, Natasha Clark, Liam Corcoran, Jenni Graham and Caroline Mortimer.

Categories

  • Finding a job
  • Comment
  • How to guides
  • Advice
  • Guest posts
  • Routes into journalism
  • Industries
Follow

  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Like us on Facebook
  • RSS feeds

Website designed & developed by push.play | go back to the top

Copyright 2012 Wannabe Hacks
More about us | Contact us | Wannabe Hacks in the news | Community Guidelines | Advertising