I am at the at the height of all my coursework and at the same time doing a work placement. So I know how 23lies feels because I have been there a few times. I chose not do the NCTJ law exam for court reporting because I had so much work to do and knew I wouldn't be able to cope. (It is not a requirement for the MA magazine course) I think there are some aspects of the course that are better tested through essay, for example how magazines work as a businesses. Chatting with a few other students we understand that you have to strike a balance between doing journalism, networking with the professionals, work experience and other projects that enhance the CV.
Are essays and exams the best way to get the most out of a journalism course?
It doesn’t take much time staring at a media law textbook two weeks before an exam to ask yourself “Christ, why am I doing this?” But rather than using my self-loathing to whine about how hard things are (they’re not really, but many seem to think their world is pretty grim) I got to thinking about what I had learnt and achieved during my year at City University studying their Newspaper Journalism MA.
Don’t worry, I’m not getting into the whole ‘are journalism courses worth it’ debate we’ve had our say on that (for now). Instead, as I sit reading about defamation cases I ponder how students get the most out of a journalism course and what the best methods are for ‘learning journalism’.
As well as revising Media law I am also writing my final essay for the course. I have enjoyed the lectures by Roy Greenslade, all of which have covered a great variety of topics in an interesting way and the two essays we have had to write following these lectures have actually been useful exercises. For example the chance to debate the ethics behind protecting sources was an interesting and pretty rewarding task. But does essay writing really make me a better journalist? Sure, I learnt a lot about the topics I have chosen to write about but is that going to enhance my work in journalism? Or is it a case that the knowledge of ethics within journalism is more important?
And then there is the media law exam itself. I’m not going to lie, I have struggled to get my head around some of the legal issues which, whilst I know are vital, I just want to forget about. But as I sit trying to cram before the test in two weeks time I wonder whether, considering the enormity of the topic and how important it can be – is one exam really enough? Am I really going to have improved my knowledge of the legal system sufficiently or will it be a case, as it often has been with me and education, that I learn it for an exam and then it is pretty much forgotten within a few months? Would the subject be more suited to regular essays on all the topics within media law? Or is it more a case that this is exam is my basic grounding and it’s on up to me to learn more?
Don’t get me wrong I have enjoyed the course and found it has benefited me in many ways. I should also point out that we have done lots of practical exercises (introductions, vox-pops, video work, production) during the year, it’s just I am thinking about the essays and exams at this present time.
I often wonder whether what I am learning will stick with me for my entire career or whether some of it is just interesting but ultimately forgettable tasks. I guess I’ll just have to let you know in a few months time. For now though it’s back to the books.
If you have studied a journalism course what aspects have you found most useful as you have progressed? Do you think essay writing should play a part in ‘learning’ journalism? Is passing a media law exam enough proof that you know your legal rights and wrongs?
Related posts:
- Forget the books, the lessons and the exams. This is why you should do a journalism course… I hate to sound a little like a broken record...
I'm really finding my journalism course useful! It is a one-year Masters program and we get chucked in the deep end - so I'm learning on the hop how to turn my skills at writing in other genres (fiction and academic, mostly) to journalistic writing. I have no journalistic experience whatsoever, so this program is definitely adding to my abilities.
I'm not one to knock essay writing - it's good to be a master of many genres, not just the one you intend to work in, and essays are afterall designed to get us studenty types thinking at a deeper level about issues that we manage to skim over the rest of the time. That said, the Masters program that I'm doing does a great job of getting us to address those issues in ways that use journalistic skills and writing - not academic essay writing skills.
I guess there's quite a few journalism students who are frustrated about theoretical or more scholarly aspects of a course. I do agree with your assessment of media law, I have an exam on Tuesday for it which will no doubt preceded by a weekend of frantic revision that serves to answer exam questions in the best way possible rather than actually learn the subject itself.
Despite that, I think that coursework isn't to be sniffed at. I'm actually right in the middle of a 2500 word essay about challenges facing political journalism...the question is really broad and difficult to structure, but it's made me consider a lot of things that I previously wouldn't have thought of. I think getting young journalists to think about concepts that are outside the here and now (which journalism is primarily concerned with) can only be a good thing as it leads to a general concise understanding of how and why news gets produced. That may not be everyone's cup of tea, but increasingly I'm finding that journalism theory excites me more than journalism practice.
@JosephStash It's not that I am turning my nose up to the coursework - I enjoyed writing the essays and the theory elements you mentioned. It's just in terms of someone, perhaps a relative or friend outside the course, asking what do you do to learn how to do journalism I'm not sure they would expect essays as an answer. That's not to say they aren't useful though
@chancer no I know, it wasn't so much aimed at you as a general thought on a wider issue. You're right - people perceive journalism as ringing people up, writing stuff down, publishing it. If I harped on about community/publicness and other meta of media I'm sure it wouldn't chime with a lot of people's perceptions of journalism. Now...back to that essay...
I'm currently doing a masters journo course and in recent weeks I've missed out on a major international and major local news scoop due to the demands of coursework that I don't feel has added anything whatsoever to my journalistic ability. All I've learned is that to be a better journalist i will have to sacrifice doing other things. It is bafflingly counter-intuitive that among the things i would be better to sacrifice is the coursework involved in my journalism training!
Podcasts
Recommended
“Embrace the fear” and other lessons from my time in student media
After finishing my stint in student media, I couldn’t help but look
Student media and a degree: getting the balance
The time is 5.09am, and the birds are twittering outside my window.
Receiving feedback and learning from criticism
I don’t know what I was expecting when I opened that email.
Comments
Andy Hamilton Bet on 4 reasons why you should start a business
Thank you for stimulating my brain with this bright and observant post. http://www.oddsbetting.co.uk/odds-history/Darts/Andy-HamiltonPosted May 14, 2013nicki_ on Applying for the Journalism Diversity Fund
Is there any chance ex-international students could apply?Posted May 10, 2013


